David McGown wrote:
Roscoe,
Thanks for the report. How would you characterize the *quality* of the bass compared with the Goldwoods? Since you are using 18 inchers in both configuration, do you think you gain anything with the slot loading?
I spent a bit of time listening last night. Bass quality is quite similar the the GW on the JEL baffle. I think the only things gained with the SLOB are the ability to use a narrower baffle and the freedom to put the rest of the drivers in the best place on the front baffle rather than having to work around the woofer. I've got a pair of these:
https://www.parts-express.com/dayton-au ... m--295-042 showing up tomorrow, and I've got the plywood to extend the wings to the rear of the base, so by this weekend I should have bass that goes as deep as it does on the JEL baffles with the GW driver.
If anyone wants to come over this weekend and critique/help me get the crossovers adjusted let me know, I plan to be around all weekend...
David McGown wrote:
I have been thinking a bit more on my cabinets, and intend on making them semi-knockdown (using carriage bolts and nuts) to fasten the top and sides together. With good solid battens and tight fasteners, it should be as good as a glue joint. If I need to make them wider in the future (say to accommodate an 18 inch driver, which my current cabinet cannot support), I can make longer top and bottom pieces and a new baffle and reassemble the cabinet. I don't want to keep building new cabinets every time I make a change.
There is another way of configuring slot loading, is to mount a driver vertically on an interior baffle behind the main baffle, comprising a chamber or slot between them, with an exit slot in the main baffle at the bottom. I was thinking about it since I do not have the depth in my current (already precut) cabinets to accommodate a 15 inch driver horizontally mounted like you have your 18's. If I make my cabinet a little wider (per above), I could slip in an 18 incher in the same manner.
David
The vertical woofer idea has possibilities, but that precludes having the bottom of the MF/HF driver(s) any lower than the top of the woofer, which wouldn't work with a tilt-back front panel like I decided to use to keep the height reasonable. You've still got to have either width or depth to get the path-length long enough... One of the cool things about the design I built is that other than the front baffle, the entire "cabinet" can be made from 2'x2' precut panels from Home Depot/Lowes which really simplifies the woodworking. The only difficult part is cutting the angle on two pieces per speaker to get the tilt-back on the front baffle.
Roscoe